SocialFacebook-01-Black logo

Fine Dining At Comfortable Prices

Closed Tuesdays

Square Square Square

Catering for all of your special events

Impress your guests with the best catering service around! Paul's Italian American Restaurant is here for all of your catering needs. We will cater anywhere within a 10 mile radius of Southampton, NY.

We will work with you to personalize and create a menu that is perfect for your unique special occasion.



Let us shelp to make your event a yummy one.

Impress your guests with the best catering in the area. Give us a call:



Veggie Lasagna

choice of white cream or red sauce


Fettuccine Alfredo

homemade alfredo sauce


Eggplant Parm

baked with mozzarella



prepared with chunks of sausage, meatballs, ricotta and mozzarella cheese



homemade manicotti with baked mozzarella


Cheese Ravioli


Eggplant Rolatine

baked with ricotta and mozzarella


Baked Ziti

ziti baked with mozzarella cheese


Penne Alla Vodka (with chicken)

with sauteed chicken breast


Penne Alla Vodka

homemade vodka sauce


Fettuccine Alfredo (with Broccoli)

with fresh broccoli


Stuffed Shells

baked with mozzarella cheese


Sausage and Pepper

white or red


Pasta Primavera

zucchini, onion, broccoli, spinach and mushrooms sauteed in garlic and oil


Pasta w/ Broccoli

in garlic and oil


Baked Ziti (w/ Ricotta)

with ricotta cheese and mozzarella

Delicious pasta your guests are sure to love!

Pasta, chicken, veal & heroes

Salads and appetizers

Start the meal off right one of our delicious and unique light salads. Or you can select a variety of appetizers to be served at your special event before the entree.


Fresh Mozz Salad

with roasted peppers and olives


Fresh Mozz Salad (with Prosciutto)

roasted peppers, olives and prosciutto


Cold Antipasto (with Prosciutto)

with Prosciutto di Parma


Cold Antipasto

with salami, provolone and marinated gardenier


Spinach Salad

with fresh mushrooms and bacon bits 


Chicken Caesar Salad

grilled chicken in homemade Caesar dressing


Caesar Salad

our homemade Caesar dressing


Rolemusbac Salad

Fresh mushrooms and bacon bits on romaine lettuce 


Grande Salad

Shredded mozzarella and tomatoes and cucumber


Gorgonzola Salad

Gorgonzola cheese with calamata olive, croutons and roasted peppers


Tossed Salad

house salad with olives, carrots, tomatoes and cucumbers


Greek Salad

feta cheese and kalamata olives

Serve your guests one of our delicious light salads.




Sesame Chicken

homemade sesame chicken strips


Calamari Vinaigrette

served on bed of lettuce with marinated gardenier


Fried Calamari

served with pomodoro or fra diavlo sauce


Hot Antipasto

fried shrimp, ravioli, clams, eggplant


Stuffed Mushrooms

homemade stuffing in fresh mushrooms


Side Meatballs/Sausages

in pomodoro sauce


Buffalo Wings

served in hot or mild sauce 


Broccoli or Spinach in Garlic and Oil



your choice of Marinara or Posillipo sauce


Steamed Broccoli or Spinach

Start the meal with an assortment of appetziers!




Chicken Picatta

with Prosciutto di Parma in lemon sauce


Chicken Francaise

buttered chicken breast in lemon sauce


Chicken Marsala

with sauteed mushrooms with Marsala wine


Chicken Cacciatore

boneless breast of chicken


Chicken and Mushroom

Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Mushroom Gravy


Chicken Margherita

Chicken breast in Marinara Sauce, topped with Fresh Mozzarella


Chicken Parm

breast of chicken with mozzarella





Veal and Mushroom

breaded veal with mushrooms in brown sauce


Veal Scallopine

in red sauce with peppers and mushrooms


Veal Marsala

with sauteed mushrooms with Marsala wine


Veal Picatta

in lemon sauce with Prosciutto di Parma


Veal Francaise

battered veal in lemon sauce


Veal Parmigiana

with mozzarella





3-6' Chicken Parm Hero


3-6' Eggplant Hero


3-6' Veal Parm Hero


3-6' Heroes Available

Cold Italian or American 


3-6' Fresh Mozz and Prosciutto

You have a selection of chicken, veal and heroes to satisfy everyone!

pauls catering Pauls place Veal