SocialFacebook-01-Black logo

Fine Dining At Comfortable Prices

Closed Tuesdays

SHRIMP COCKTAIL (4)  - $13.25

Cold

Start your meal with one of our fresh and delicious appetizers.

Appetizers

For food that is made fresh daily, come to Paul's Italian American Restaurant!

631-283-1861

Salads

Our Dressings are: House, Caesar, Ranch or Russian or Balsamic Vingaigrette (Bleu Cheese .95 Extra)

Desserts

Beverages

Wraps

Wraps are available in a pita pocket or in a roll for an additional charge.

Lite delites

Specialty sandwiches

A sandwich like you have never had before!

Pizza (neapolitan)

TOPPINGS:

½ Pie 1.95

Whole Pie 3.00

Pan pizza

You won't be sorry you ordered one of our delicious pan pizzas!

Heros

Burgers

Side dishes

Complete your meal with one of our side dishes

Soup

Pasta specialties

CHOICE OF FRESH PASTA:

SPAGHETTI - LINGUINE - ZITI - CAPPELLINI

(RIGATONI, PENNE, FUSILLI PASTA 1.00 EXTRA)

[WHOLE WHEAT PENNE & LINGUINE 1.25 EXTRA]

(GLUTEN FREE PENNE 2.00 extra)

Try one of our filling and unique pasta specialties today!

Seafood pasta specialties

ZUPPE DE PESCE

For one  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .   30.95

For two  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57.00

mussels, clams, calamari, shrimp and fresh local

flounder sauteed in a delicate fish marinara sauce,

served with linguine

All pastas are served with salad and garlic bread

Pasta sides

SIDE of PASTA with:

Entrees

ITALIAN CLASSICS

SEAFOOD

FROM THE BROILER

CHICKEN, VEAL

With our wide selection of entrees, you can't go wrong!

Children's menu

$7.50

Under 12 Only

Served with Small Fountain Soda

PLATE OF STEAMED VEGGIES

SPAGHETTI  or ZITTI with meatball or sausage

CHICKEN FINGERS and french fries

GRILLED AMERICAN CHEESE and french fries

CHICKEN PARMIGIANA with spaghetti

♣CHEESEBURGER and french fries

RAVIOLI - LASAGNA

Pauls sandwich Tiramisu dessert Fresh shrimps salad wraps lite-delites sandwich pizza pan-pizza heros burger onion rings pasta seafood pasta pasta-sides entrees meatballs pasta

From sandwich kitchen to long island favorite, we are grateful to all our faithful employees and patrons, and look forward to the new.

SOUTHWESTERN WRAP - $10.25                                

TERIYAKI SHRIMP WRAP - $13.50                                  

grilled chicken pepperoncini, salsa & mixed greens

sauteed onions, roasted peppers & mixed greens

PAUL'S STEAK WRAP - $13.50                                  

sauteed onions, roasted peppers & mixed greens

TERIYAKI CHICKEN WRAP - $10.50                            

with avocado and tomato and mixed greens with teriyaki chicken.

VEGGIE WHOLE WHEAT WRAP - $10.25

grilled eggplant with avocado, roasted peppers, tomatoes & mixed greens with balsamic vinaigrette

CHICKEN QUESADILLA - $10.75                          

chicken and sauteed peppers and onions with melted cheddar and mozzarella served with salsa and sour cream

HOUSE SALAD - $4.95                                          

DOUBLE HOUSE SALAD - $8.50                                  

GRANDE MOZZARELLA SALAD - $10.95                      

mozzarella, tomato & cucumber

ROLEMUSBAC SALAD - $10.95                                      

mozzarella, tomato & cucumber

romaine lettuce, mushrooms & bacon bits

GREEK SALAD - $11.50                                              

feta cheese & greek olives

CAESAR SALAD                                              

in our own homemade caesar dressing

FRESH MOZZARELLA SALAD - $11.75                        

with sun dried tomatoes, roasted peppers & black olives served over our mixed green salad (with prosciutto di parma - $3.75 extra)

GORGONZOLA SALAD - $11.50                              

on mesclun lettuce with roasted peppers, croutons and calamata olives

GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD - $12.75            

grilled chicken with homemade croutons & grated romano cheese mixed with romaine lettuce in our own caesar dressing

GRILLED SHRIMP CAESAR SALAD - $13.95          

grilled shrimp with homemade croutons & grated romano cheese mixed with romaine lettuce in our own caesar dressing

CHEF'S SALAD - $12.25                                            

roasted beef, ham, turkey, American & Swiss cheese

Try something from the lighter side of our lunch menu.

GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST PLATTER - $12.95            

GRILLED SHRIMP & VEGETABLE PLATTER - $15.25      

SPINACH CHICKEN DELITE - $11.50

VEGGIE MESCLUN SALAD - $11.50  

GRILLED EGGPLANT - $10.95  

with choice of steamed vegetable

(grilled or sauteed available for an extra charge)

over risotto with eggplant, zucchini, roasted peppers & tomato

served on baby-leaf spinach with bacon bits, hard boiled egg, roasted peppers & diced cucumbers

with avocado, tomatoes, grilled eggplant, roasted peppers & portabello mushroom over mesclun greens

on Italian rustic bread with tomato, fresh mozzarella & balsamic marinated mesculin greens, served with house salad

HAM, TUNA or PASTRAMI MELT - $10.95                    

♣ HAM or ROAST BEEF or TURKEY DELUXE - $11.95

on hero with choice of cheese melted, with lettuce and tomato

on hero with bacon, choice of cheese melted, with lettuce and tomato

♣ ROAST BEEF PARMIGIANA - $11.50                        

on garlic bread with mozzarella, lettuce and tomato

ITIALIAN HERO (the original) - $10.95                                

salami, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion and house dressing

GRILLED CHICKEN DELUXE - $10.25                              

with lettuce, tomato, bacon & mozzarella on whole grain roll

SEA GRINDER - $11.25                                                    

fresh filet of flounder with lettuce, tomato and your choice of cheese

♣ CLUB SANDWICH - $11.25                                          

turkey, ham or roast beef with lettuce, tomato and bacon

REUBEN - $10.75                                                            

pastrami on rye with russian dressing and sauerkraut

THE GODFATHER - $10.95                                                

salami and fresh mozzarella with roasted peppers, shredded lettuce and tomato, sprinkled with house dressing.

THE GODMOTHER - $12.75                                        

prosciutto di parma and provolone on a hero with lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers and house dressing.

♣ PHILLY CHEESE STEAK - $11.95                            

sauteed onions and roast beef with cheddar cheese on toasted buttered hero

FRESH MOZZARELLA HERO - $10.50                        

fresh mozzarella, vine-ripe tomatoes, green leaf lettuce, roasted peppers and basil with Italian dressing

CHICKEN AVOCADO CLUB - $11.50                            

grilled chicken & avocado with lettuce, tomato & bacon

BLACK RUSSIAN - $10.95                                            

pastrami, bacon & tomato with Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on hero

CHICKEN DI PARMA - $11.95                                      

chicken cutlet with roasted peppers, proscuitto di parma with melted mozzarella on garlic bread

ROAST TURKEY & FRESH MOZZARELLA - $11.25  

vine-ripe tomatoes with fresh basil and balsamic vinaigrette, served on hero

(with choice of fries $1.95 extra)

TOPPINGS - $1.25 extra                                                  

(Seafood not included)

CHEESE - $15.25                                                                

WHOLE WHEAT & 10' GLUTEN FREE PIZZA AVAILABLE

OLIVES - $17.25                                                                

SHRIMP - $24.25

ANCHOVIES - $17.25

FRESH GARLIC - $17.25

SAUSAGE - $17.25

MEATBALLS - $17.25

FRESH PEPPERS - $17.25

FRESH MUSHROOMS - $17.50

ONIONS - $17.25

SALAMI - $17.25

EGGPLANT - $17.25

PEPPERONI - $17.25

FRESH BROCCOLI - $17.50

FRESH BASIL & MOZZARELLA - $20.25

WHITE PIZZA - $20.75

PESTO & PLUM TOMATO - $20.95

PAUL'S SPECIAL - $20.75

sausage, meatball, pepper and onion

HAMPTON GARDEN - $20.75

broccoli, mushrooms, olives, fresh garlic and artichoke hearts

SICILIAN - $20.25

ANY PIZZA CAN BE MADE WITH THIN CRUST UPON REQUEST

CHEESE - $10.25                                                                  

VEGGIE - $11.75                                                            

mushrooms, eggplant, onion & olives

SEAFOOD - $14.95                                                              

shrimp and clams

CALZONES - $8.25

fried or baked to order prepared with ham, ricotta and mozzarella (extra toppings $0.95 each)

(each additional shrimp - $3.75)

♣ CLAMS on the ½ SHELL                                    

dozen - $13.50                                                                      

½ dozen - $8.25                                                                  

ANTIPASTO

small - $13.50                                                                    

large - $15.75                                                                      

(with prosciutto di parma - $3.75 extra)

FRESH MOZZARELLA & TOMATO APPETIZER - $11.95

served with fresh basil, roasted peppers and vine-ripe tomatoes and extra virgin olive oil

FETTUCCINE ALFREDO - $10.75                              

Hot

FETTUCCINE ALFREDO w/ BROCCOLI - $12.50        

FRIED ZUCCHINI - $8.25                                                

MOZZARELLA STICKS - $6.50                                      

COMBO CLASSIC - $8.75                                                  

zucchini, cheese sticks & fried mushrooms

BUFFALO WINGS (small - 10) - $9.75                        

spicy hot or mild (large - 20) - $16.95                            

CHICKEN FINGERS

small - $7.25                                                                      

large - $8.50                                                                      

POTATO SKINS - $6.25                                

served with bacon bits, cheddar and sour cream

GARLIC BREAD - $3.75                                                

with mozzarella - $7.25                                                        

w/ sun dried tomatoes & mozzarella - $7.95                    

w/ fresh basil. tomato and garlic - $8.25                              

STIR-FRY VEGETABLE PLATTER -  $12.75                        

zucchini, broccoli, onion, spinach, ushrooms & roasted peppers

HOT ANTIPASTO - $17.95                          

fried shrimp, fried ravioli, baked clams & eggplant, rollatine w/ roasted peppers

BAKED CLAMS OREGANO (1 dozen) - $16.50      

chopped $1.00 extra (½ dozen - 9.75) - $9.75

CLAMS CASINO w/ bacon & fresh garlic

1 dozen - $16.50                                                          

½ dozen - $9.75                                                              

SHRIMP OREGANATO - $13.95                                      

SHRIMP SCAMPI - $13.95  

SHRIMP MARINARA - $13.95

SHRIMP FRA DIAVOLO - $13.95

MUSSELS MARINARA - $12.50

MUSSELS FRA DIAVOLO - $12.50

MUSSELS POSSILIPO - $12.50

STEAMED MUSSELS - $11.50

FRIED CALAMARI - $12.95

FRIED JUMBO SHRIMP (4) - $14.95

OUR DRESSINGS ARE:

House, Caesar, Ranch, Russian or Balsamic Vinaigrette

(Bleu Cheese $0.95 extra)

FRIES - $3.60                                                                      

french fries, waffle fries, shoe string fries or sweet potato fries

ONION RINGS - $4.25                                                

MEATBALLS - $6.75                                                  

SAUSAGE - $6.75                                                            

BAKED POTATO (after 5 pm) - $4.95                            

VEGETABLE of the DAY - $7.50                                    

spinach or broccoli (sauteed vegetables extra)

PASTA POMODORO - $15.95                                      

our own homemade tomato sauce

PASTA with MEAT SAUCE - $17.25                                  

our homemade meat sauce

PASTA MARINARA - $16.50                                            

prepared with imported Italian tomatoes & olive oil

POMODORO w/ Meatball or Sausage -  $17.50                

PRIMAVERA - $19.25                                                          

zucchini, broccoli, carrots, spinach, onion & mushrooms, sauteed in garlic & olive oil

AGLIO & OLIO - $16.75                                                    

sauteed garlic & extra virgin olive oil

MUSHROOM SAUCE -$17.75                                      

light red sauce

BASIL, GARLIC & VIRGIN OLIVE OIL - $17.95            

FETTUCCINI ALFREDO - $18.50                                        

TORTELLINI ALFREDO - 18.95                                      

FETTUCCINE CARBONARA ALFREDO - $20.95    

with imported prosciutto di parma fresh mushroom & onions

GNOCCHI POMODORO - $16.95                                  

GNOCCHI w/ PESTO - $19.50                                        

GNOCCHI & FRESH MOZZARELLA - $18.95                

in marinara sauce w/ fresh basil

CAVATELLI in POMODORO SAUCE - $17.25              

CAVATELLI w/ RICOTTA - $17.95                            

in pomodoro sauce

PENNE ALLA VODKA - $18.95                                      

PENNE w/ BROCCOLI, OIL & GARLIC - $18.95          

RAVIOLI - $17.25                                                            

BAKED RAVIOLI - $18.25                                        

SPINACH RAVIOLI - $17.50                                        

SPINACH RAVIOLI w/ VODKA SAUCE - $19.50          

BAKED LASAGNA - $16.95                                        

BAKED HOMEMADE MANICOTT - $16.95                  

STUFFED SHELLS -  $16.75                                        

BAKED ZITTI PARMIGIANA - $16.50                      

with RICOTTA - $17.50                                              

A hot hero for every taste. Try them all!

♣ STEAK - $14.25                                                                  

with sauteed onions and cheese

EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA - $9.95                                      

VEAL CUTLET PARMIGIANA - $12.50                                

SHRIMP PARMIGIANA - $14.25                                    

SAUSAGE & PEPPERS - $10.25                                  

MEATBALL PARMIGIANA - $9.95                          

MEATBALL & SAUSAGE PARMIGIANA - $9.95        

SAUSAGE PARMIGIANA - $9.95                                  

CHICKEN CUTLET PARMIGIANA - $10.75                    

SHRIMP PARMIGIANA  - $14.25                                  

(with choice of fries 1.95 extra)

Our ½ lb. burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce, tomatoes, choice of fries, house salad, steamed vegetables or baked potato (after 5:00 PM)

♣ HAMBURGER PLATTER - $9.25                                

CHEESE BURGER PLATTER - $9.95                          

BACON CHEESE BURGER - $10.75                                

PIZZA BURGER PLATTER - $10.25                                  

TURKEY BURGER PLATTER - $9.50                          

PORTABELLO BURGER PLATTER - $8.95                      

LINGUINE w/ CLAM SAUCE - $19.95                            

fresh local chopped clams in white or light red sauce

LINGUINE w/ SHRIMP & CLAMS - $23.95                      

served with white or light red sauce

STEAMED CLAMS over LINGUINE - $20.95                      

fresh local clams steamed in white or light red sauce

LINGUINE MARECHIARE - $24.95                                

clams, shrimp & mussels in marinara sauce

SHRIMP MARINARA - $24.95                                          

shrimp sauteed lightly in marinara sauce over linguine

SHRIMP FRA DIAVOLO - $24.95                                    

SHRIMP in ANGEL HAIR - $24.95                                    

shrimp sauteed lightly in our own garlic butter & herbs, served over capellini

SCUNGILLI ALLA MARINARA - $22.50                        

SCUNGILLI FRA DIAVOLO - $22.50                            

sauteed in light marinara sauce with white wine, garlic & herbs over linguine

CALAMARI ALLA MARINARA - $22.50                          

CALAMARI FRA DIAVOLO - $22.50                                

sauteed in light marinara sauce with white wine, garlic & herbs over linguine

MUSSELS MARINARA - $21.95                              

local mussels sauteed in light marinara sauce with white wine, garlic & herbs over linguine

MUSSELS POSILLIPO - $21.95                                

local mussels sauteed with garlic, herbs & white wine over linguine

SEAFOOD SIZZLER - $25.95                                    

combination of broiled shrimp, fresh flounder & scallops in our oreganata breading, served with a side of red or white clam sauce.

MUSHROOM SAUCE - $9.75                                          

CLAM SAUCE red or white - $12.95                              

MEAT SAUCE - $9.75        

PESTO SAUCE - $10.75  

MARINARA SAUCE - $8.95    

Italian classics

VEAL CUTLET PARMIGIANA - $23.50

pomodoro sauce & mozzarella cheese

BREAST of CHICKEN CUTLET PARMIGIANA - $22.50

pomodoro sauce & mozarella

CHICKEN CUTLET & PEPPERS PARMIGIANA - $22.95

breast of chicken, fresh peppers & mozzarella

BAKED EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA - $19.50

breaded eggplant, layered with pomodoro sauce, grated cheese & mozzarella

BAKED EGGPLANT ROLLATINI - $20.95

breaded eggplant, layered with ricotta, pomodoro sauce, grated cheese & mozzarella

Seafood

JUMBO SHRIMP OREGANATO - $24.95

shrimp broiled in garlic butter & white wine, lightly topped w/ seasoned bread crumbs

JUMBO SHRIMP SCAMPI - $24.95

delicately sauteed in garlic butter

JUMBO SHRIMP PARMIGIANA - $24.95

fried shrimp in pomodoro sauce topped w/ mozzarella cheese

JUMBO FRIED SHRIMP - $24.95

friend shrimp served with tartar sauce

JUMBO SHRIMP FRANCESE - $24.95

delightfully sauteed & served in our white wine & lemon sauce

BROILED LOCAL FLOUNDER (in season)

broiled in flavorful spices & lightly topped with our seasoned bread crumbs

From the broiler

EXTRA THIC CUT DINNER STEAK - $25.95

MARINATED EXTRA THICK CUT - $25.95

ROAST HALF CHICKEN - $19.50

FRIED SEAFOOD PLATTER

delicately fried flounder, scallops, calamari & shrimp

STEAMED SEAFOOD PLATTER

clams, mussels & shrimp

Chicken

BREAST of CHICKEN MARSALA - $23.95

breast of chicken in marsala wine w/ mushrooms

BREAST of CHICKEN PICCATA - $23.95

breast of chicken sauteed in white wine w/ lemon, herbs & prosciutto di parma

BREAST of CHICKEN FRANCESE - $23.95

breast of chicken sauteed in butter w/ white wine & lemon

CHICKEN CACCIATORE - $20.95

served w/ fresh peppers, onions & fresh mushrooms

CHICKEN MARGHERITA - $22.95

sauteed chicken breast w/ plum tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic, oil, white wine & herbs, topped w/ fresh mozzarella

Veal

VEAL SCALLOPINE CACCIATORE - $24.95

fresh mushrooms, onions, peppers in a light marinara sauce

VEAL PICCATA PASTA - $24.95

veal sauteed in white wine, lemon & herbs w/ prosciutto di parma

VEAL FRANCESE PASTA - $24.95

veal delicately sauteed in white wine & herbs w/ lemon

VEAL MARSALA PASTA - $24.95

sauteed in marsala wine w/ mushrooms

VEAL MILANESE - $23.95

breaded veal cutlet w/ a wege of lemon or served in our pomodoro sauce

Specialty coffees

CREME DE LA

coffee, bailey's creme de cacao

FRENCH KISS

amaretto, kahlua, hot chocolate, coffee

TOASTED NUT

frangelica, kahlua, hot chocolate, coffee

KEOKI COFFEE

kahlua, brandy & coffee

IRISH COFFEE

bushmill irish whiskey, kahlua & coffee

We serve Cappuccino & Espresso

We proudly serve... "CHAI"

A Tea unlike any other you've tasted!

Beer & Wine

IMPORTED & DOMESTIC

TAP BEER AVAILABLE

HOUSE WINE AVAILABLE

by the Glass - ½ Carafe - Full Carafe

complete wine list available

Desserts

ASK ABOUT OUR DESSERTS

Coffee

Soup

ZUPPA DEL GIORNO

cup

bowl

super bowl

ONION AU GRATIN

Serving the best food for over 40 years

We have grown from a small sandwich shop with just a few items on the menu to the extensive menu you see below. There is so much to choose from you won't know where to begin! The good news is it is all great so you will never go wrong!

CLAMS POSILLIPO white or light red sauce

1 dozen - $14.95                                                          

½ dozen - $9.50                                                              

small - $8.95                                                                      

large - $5.25                                                                      

All Pasta Entrees service with sald and Garlic Bread

 

(Bleu Cheeses Derssing .95 extra) - Please no substitution)

 

Mini Caesar Salad $2.25 extra

 

Request for Mushroom Sauce, Clam Suace, pesto or Marinara Suace or any other specially  prepared sauce will result in an additional charge.

 

VEAL CUTLET & PEPPER  PARMIGIANA - $23.95

fresh peppers and mozzarella cheese

for one - $24.95 | for two - $46.95

for one - $24.95 | for two - $45.95

♣ These menu itmes can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undrcooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh eggs may increase your risk of food  borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.